Madge,
That is NOT a case history! When was he originally diagnosed as MSA and WHO did
the diagnoses? How did "Dr. Khalaf Bushara, a Movement Disorder Specialist,
first saw Al in Oct., 2000 at the VA Medical Center in Minneapolis" diagnose Al
as MSA when all his MSA symptoms were gone already for 12 months or more? Who
decided to take Al off of the medicines - a doctor, you or a acupuncturist?
When did Al come off the medicines? What are Al's current MSA symptoms?
My wife's diagnoses includes notes on why the neurologists thought it was MSA
and included info on tests for:
MRI's over a 5 year span - told where specifally there was visible atrophy
EEG and nerve conduction tests - told which nerves were doing their jobs and
which were not
Did Al have these tests? What were the results? Did he show atrophy of the
cerebellar pons , whole brain, or exactly what areas of the brain?
Do his records have words like cogwheeling, cerebellar ataxia, dysphagia,
bradykinesia, vestibular ataxia, dysarthria, nystagmus, blepharospasm,
amyotrophy, corticospinal tract signs,
sleep apnea, stridor, hyperreflexia. and extensor plantar responses. cerebellar
or pyrramidal tract signs, akinesia, limb dystonia, cortical myoclonus. Some of
these words will be found in a case history of MSA, but not all. While every
case is different, there are common symptoms. If the symptoms are gone - how do
you say it was MSA, since MSA is (at this time) only a set of symptoms.
Another discrepancy with this treatment is that in MSA brain cells die. How do
you grow new brain cells by sticking needles into their bodies. If somehow
sticking the needles into the body caused dopamine producing neurons to grow
where you stuck the needles, how would they get across the blood/brain barrier.
If hallucinations are Al's major problem, taking him off of Sinemet, should cure
the hallucinations in 30 days (at most), yet you say he has been off of Sinemet
and all PD medicines for 16 months. How can you blame a protein for
hallucinations when you have not had that protein for 16 months. Proteins do
last in the body for days and possibly weeks, but not months.
You have never mentioned how Al regained muscle strength. Did he have extended
physical therapy? Muscles can not heal themselves from atrophy without
stretching them. You said that Al was helpless for three years in one of your
emails, yet popped right up off the table after one session of acupuncture.
Even if the acupuncture cured nerve problems, how did the muscles regain
strength without therapy?
I'm sorry, but if you insist on saying this woman can cure MSA, please make sure
Al had MSA. Many here took 5-7 years before doctors told them they had MSA and
many tests. It bothers me that it took 14 doctors at NIH plus 4 other
neurologists who were movement disorder specialists to decide that my wife
"probably" had MSA and your neurologist can say with one visit and no tests (15
months after Al had no more symptoms) that he definitely HAD MSA. If the
symptoms are gone - Al is cured! And he was "cured" by a woman whose specialty
is curing yeast infections with acupuncture. She has no neurological training,
yet she cures dead brain cells with pins.
Do you realize that some doctors have been saying for years that Johnny Cash had
MSA and some are now saying that he had diabetes all the time? I also do not
understand why you go to a VA hospital in Minneapolis, when you live in
Florida. I thought you had to live near the hospital you used in VA cases. You
mentioned going to Dr. Mark Hallet at NIH (NINDS) months ago, why hasn't he seen
Al?
I don't want to say that Alternative Medicine can not help at all. Obviously
that is how many medicines were discovered (like aspirin). We do know that
therapy and lots of liquids help MSA patients. But I can not conceive of a way
that sticking pins in someone can cure dead brain cells. I also can not
conceive of a acupuncturist telling you to stop taking medicines that a doctor
prescribed. Dropping medicines like florinef can kill a person. Dropping
others suddenly can also kill you.
This list is NOT the place for advertising of unproven treatments which go
against your doctor's advice. If Al had MSA show us his records in detail. I
am sure you could share them with Dr. Robertson at Vanderbilt, who IS an expert
in this disorder. The only movement disorder specialist I can find in Minnesota
is:
Dr. Paola Sandroni
Mayo Clinic
Dept. of Neurology
200 First Street SW
Rochester, MN 55905
Phone: (507) 284-2511
That's my opinion, Bill Werre